Circle Liquidity case study

Liquidity Case Study | PUBLISHED APRIL 2026
Liquidity Event

IPO, June 2025

Time to liquidity

12.03 Months

Net IRR*

115.48%

Net MOIC**

2.1x

Figures represent the median Equitybee investor
About circle's ipo

Circle Internet Group is a U.S.-based financial technology company and the issuer of USDC, one of the world's most widely used dollar-pegged stablecoins. Founded in 2013 by Jeremy Allaire and Sean Neville, Circle has raised over $1.5 billion in venture funding from leading institutions including BlackRock, Fidelity, Goldman Sachs, and General Catalyst.

On June 4, 2025, Circle priced its initial public offering at $31 per share on the NYSE under the ticker CRCL, above its expected range of $24-$28, raising approximately $1.1 billion and valuing the company at approximately $6.9 billion (CNBC). When trading opened the next day, shares surged to $69 at open and closed at $83.23, a 168% first-day gain, marking one of the strongest fintech IPO debuts of the year (CoinDesk).Circle's path to the public markets included a $9 billion SPAC deal with Concord Acquisition Corp that was terminated in December 2022 after the SEC did not declare the S-4 effective by the deadline. The company ultimately pursued a traditional IPO, filing its S-1 in early 2025.

Circle Investments with Equitybee

In October 2024, Equitybee facilitated the funding of stock option packages for Circle employees. Approximately 12 months after funding, Circle successfully went public via IPO, delivering positive returns to all investors via Equitybee.

How Did Returns Through Equitybee Perform Compared to Leading VCs?

Circle's IPO at $31 per share generated strong returns for Equitybee investors. Notably, Equitybee investors achieved a median net IRR of 115.48% with only 12 months to liquidity, significantly outperforming the estimated annualized returns of Circle's most recent venture round investors. We estimate that Series F investors, including BlackRock, Fidelity, and Goldman Sachs, who invested at $42.14 per share in April 2022, achieved an estimated net IRR of approximately 18.88% over roughly 44 months. By comparison, Equitybee investors entered at $16.18 per share, a 62% discount to the Series F price, and realized over 6x the estimated annualized return in roughly one-quarter of the time.

Broad Access
By funding startup employees' stock options, Equitybee opens the door for investors to participate in virtually any pre-IPO company. As of the date this case study was published, investors on the platform have funded employee stock options in over 870 startups, spanning sectors from SaaS and fintech to AI and consumer technology.
Discounted Entry Price
By funding employee stock options, Equitybee investors accessed Circle at significantly earlier and lower valuations than traditional late-stage investors. In October 2024, the Equitybee offer entry price was $16.18 per share, nearly identical to the Series E preferred price of $16.23 per share set in 2018, and representing a 62% discount versus the $42.14 per share paid by Series F investors in 2022. This pricing advantage was a key driver of the superior IRR achieved by Equitybee investors.

Earlier Valuations, Faster Liquidity

Entry Price
Months to Liquidity
Net IRR

Equitybee Investors*

$16.18
12.03
115.48%

Series F Investors

$42.14
43.8
~18.88%

Series E Investors

$16.23
92.8
~22.96%

Series D Investors

$2.76
115.4
~42.33%

Series C Investors

$2.17
128.4
~40.51%

Series B Investors

$0.97
141.7
~45.83%

Series A Investors

$0.27
146.6
~60.14%

*Equitybee Investors figures represent the median Equitybee investor. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Investment entry prices vs. Net IRR

Notably, the median net IRR for Equitybee offers on Circle was 115.48%. Equitybee investors entered at $16.18 per share in late 2024, a price effectively on par with Series E investors who entered at $16.23 in 2018. However, while we estimate Series E investors waited nearly 93 months for liquidity and achieved an estimated net IRR of approximately 22.96%, Equitybee investors achieved their return in just over 12 months.We estimate that Series F investors, who entered at $42.14 per share in April 2022, achieved an estimated net IRR of approximately 18.88% over roughly 44 months. Earlier-stage investors benefited from significantly lower entry prices: Series A investors entered at $0.27 per share in October 2013, and Series B investors at $0.97 per share in March 2014. These early rounds, however, required capital commitments of over a decade before achieving liquidity.

Methodology note:
Our estimates for venture round investors are based on: (1) the preferred share prices paid in each round (as outlined in the Timeline of Events), (2) Circle's settlement price of approximately $78.5 per share, calculated as the weighted average closing price during the first five trading days following the lockup expiration, and (3) a 1:1 conversion from preferred to common shares at IPO. These estimates assume venture investors sold at the settlement price described above. Actual VC fund returns may differ.

From Investment to Liquidity

Timeline Of Events

Oct 2013
Circle Completes Series A

Preferred Share Price: $0.27 | Lead Investors: General Catalyst, Accel, SharesPost

Mar 2014
Circle Completes Series B

Preferred Share Price: $0.97 | Lead Investors: General Catalyst, Accel, Oak Investment Partners

Apr 2015
Circle Completes Series C

Preferred Share Price: $2.17 | Lead Investors: General Catalyst, Accel, Oak Investment Partners | Funding: ~$50M at ~$200M valuation

May 2016
Circle Completes Series D

Preferred Share Price: $2.76 | Lead Investors: General Catalyst, Accel, Oak Investment Partners | Funding: ~$60M

Apr 2018
Circle Completes Series E

Preferred Share Price: $16.23 | Lead Investors: Next Ventures, Sequoia Capital, BlackRock, FTX

Apr 2022
Circle Completes Series F

Preferred Share Price: $42.14 | Lead Investors: BlackRock, Fidelity, Goldman Sachs | Funding: $400M at ~$9B valuation

Oct 2024
Equitybee Offer Funded

Offer Price: $16.18 per share | 62% discount vs. Series F ($42.14)

Jun 2025
Circle IPO on NYSE (CRCL)

IPO Price: $31.00 per share | Raised: ~$1.1B | Valuation: ~$6.9B

Nov 2025
Lockup Expiration

Lockup period expired on November 13, 2025. Settlement date: November 21, 2025.

Dec 2025
Equitybee Distribution

Distribution Price: $78.5092 per share | Distribution Date: December 5, 2025

Equitybee Investors Returns

Liquidity Event

IPO, June 2025

Time to liquidity

12.03 Months

Net IRR*

115.48%

Net MOIC**

2.1x

Figures represent the median Equitybee investor

Ready to get access?

Join the success of hundreds of investors who made it with Equitybee

870+
Startups
Equitybee investors have funded employee stock options in.
280
Liquidity events
280 unique liquidity events from 211 different companies.
$271M+
Total Volume
Equitybee facilitated over $271 million in total transaction volume.
73%
Median Discount
Compared to the last known preferred share price paid by investors on the cap table.
28.4
Avg # of months to liquidity
For investments that reached liquidity, the average time to return was 28.4 months
4,000+
Customers
Over 4,000 startup employees and investors world wide

*Internal Rate of Return, net of fees
**Multiple on Invested Capital Past performance is not indicative of future results.
115.48% IRR represents the median IRR experienced by investors who utilized Equitybee to fund employee stock options in Circle. Net IRR is shown net of all applicable fees. IRR figures are calculated for each offer on the Equitybee platform from the date the investor's funds were transferred to the employee (funded date) through the distribution date of proceeds. If the distribution date was less than one year after the funded date, the IRR represents an unannualized return. For distributions one year or more after the funded date, IRR is annualized. Circle public share prices sourced through Yahoo! Finance. Equitybee is not affiliated or associated with, or endorsed by, any of the companies mentioned herein. Equitybee executes private financing contracts (PFCs), private placements which are speculative, illiquid, contain substantial risk and may result in the complete loss of capital to the investor. These risks may be greater during extreme market conditions. PFCs do not grant or transfer ownership of startup company stock. When a liquidity event occurs at a price per share less than the investment price per share, Investors will first receive all available funds to recoup the original investment amount. The employee will not receive any proceeds in this event. A private offering of interests will only be made pursuant to a confidential private placement memorandum, an operating agreement, and other subscription documents ('Other Documents'), which will only be furnished to qualified investors on a confidential basis at their request for their consideration in connection with such offering. For accredited investors only. Securities offered through EquityBee Securities, LLC, member FINRA.

Sources:
Circle IPO Pricing Announcement - CNBC
Circle NYSE Debut and First-Day Performance - CoinDesk
Circle IPO Valuation and Pricing Details - CoinDesk
Circle $400M Series F Funding Round - TechCrunch
Circle IPO Pricing Details - Circle Investor Relations
Circle SPAC Termination - Circle Press Room
Fundraising round data - Pitchbook, Inc.